Back in August 10 of us attempted a college football fantasy draft. We got the idea from here. The ten of us drafted out the 120 teams. With just he bowl remaining I have the lead, but anything can happen.
I thought I'd break down the "best" and "worst" picks in each round.
Round 1: Boise St (Dad) - Florida State (Mason)
Round 2: Arkansas (Cory) - Akron (Kevin)
Round 3: Northern Illinois (Dad) - Troy (Cory)
Round 4: Houston (Melissa) - Maryland (Kara)
Round 5: Arkansas State (Kevin) - Army (Andy)
Round 6: Ohio (Laura) - Oregon State (Mike)
Round 7: Temple/Florida Intl (Dad/Jesse) - BC (Mason)
Round 8: Penn State (Mike) - Idaho/MTSU (Dad/Mason)
Round 9: Kansas State/La Tech (Kara/Laura) - Colorado (Kevin)
Round 10: Wyoming (Mason) - Indiana (Kara)
Round 11: Utah State (Laura) - Mississippi (Mason)
Round 12: La Lafayette (Jesse) - New Mexico (Mason)
Showing posts with label Draft. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Draft. Show all posts
Sunday, December 11, 2011
Monday, August 29, 2011
Friday, April 29, 2011
Dragging out the NFL draft
I'm not a fan of the extended 3-day NFL draft. I didn't watch any of the draft coverage last night. I understand it went on past midnight.
The first round always took too long, but who cared on a Saturday afternoon. But if the choice is watching Berman and Kiper talk for 15 minutes between picks or watching Community, The Office, Parks & Rec and 30 Rock, the NFL draft loses every time.
For those of you who chose to waste time watching the draft instead - here are the NBC shows update -SPOILER ALERT - if you're waiting to watch them on your DVR
Community - Shirley had her baby - it was Andre's not Chang's
The Office - Michael's last episode - he was telling everyone he had one more day, but left a day early to head out to Boulder (he had to call Holly to find out where they were going to live)
Parks & Rec - Jerry's painting for the Pawnee govt art project showed Leslie as a topless centaur and Tom as a cherub. The townspeople were not happy with the nudity - but Leslie and Jerry tricked them in the end
30 Rock - Jack's wife Avery was arrested in North Korea. Liz was empowered by realizing she fixes all the problems on TGS, she should be able to do the same in her life. A plastic bag stuck in a tree becomes her white whale.
Meanwhile - Fairly seems like a nice get for the Lions!
I'm not sure how much of the later rounds I'll watch over the next couple days, probably not as much as I used to when the Draft first came to weekend television, that's for sure.
The first round always took too long, but who cared on a Saturday afternoon. But if the choice is watching Berman and Kiper talk for 15 minutes between picks or watching Community, The Office, Parks & Rec and 30 Rock, the NFL draft loses every time.
For those of you who chose to waste time watching the draft instead - here are the NBC shows update -SPOILER ALERT - if you're waiting to watch them on your DVR
Community - Shirley had her baby - it was Andre's not Chang's
The Office - Michael's last episode - he was telling everyone he had one more day, but left a day early to head out to Boulder (he had to call Holly to find out where they were going to live)
Parks & Rec - Jerry's painting for the Pawnee govt art project showed Leslie as a topless centaur and Tom as a cherub. The townspeople were not happy with the nudity - but Leslie and Jerry tricked them in the end
30 Rock - Jack's wife Avery was arrested in North Korea. Liz was empowered by realizing she fixes all the problems on TGS, she should be able to do the same in her life. A plastic bag stuck in a tree becomes her white whale.
Meanwhile - Fairly seems like a nice get for the Lions!
I'm not sure how much of the later rounds I'll watch over the next couple days, probably not as much as I used to when the Draft first came to weekend television, that's for sure.
Monday, April 27, 2009
draft, etc.
I didn't pay too much attention to the draft. I saw the first day picks for the Lions on Saturday night and wondered, also about the TE so early, and the MAC safety. He may be as good as they say, but it is a risk. As almost any pick would be, of course.
As far as Cowherd, I feel fortunate I can't hear him in my office. Based on the last few things you have mentioned, he likes to quantify things, but does it in such simplified terms that it doesn't make sense. In this case, for instance, if Pettigrew starts 6 games, but the coaches realize his ability and switch up the offense so the next few years are more geared to the TE, and he ends up being all pro 6 times in the next 8 years, and a possible HOF'er, Cowheard's measurement would just be '6 starts'. I'd say it was a great draft pick.
Secondly, starts are not very important in some positions (WR, for instance) but very important in others (QB).
Look at Advanced NFL Stats. There is a lot of analysis on the draft (at least before it, i haven't read anything from after the draft yet). That site makes simplistic statements like the above referenced look silly.
As far as Cowherd, I feel fortunate I can't hear him in my office. Based on the last few things you have mentioned, he likes to quantify things, but does it in such simplified terms that it doesn't make sense. In this case, for instance, if Pettigrew starts 6 games, but the coaches realize his ability and switch up the offense so the next few years are more geared to the TE, and he ends up being all pro 6 times in the next 8 years, and a possible HOF'er, Cowheard's measurement would just be '6 starts'. I'd say it was a great draft pick.
Secondly, starts are not very important in some positions (WR, for instance) but very important in others (QB).
Look at Advanced NFL Stats. There is a lot of analysis on the draft (at least before it, i haven't read anything from after the draft yet). That site makes simplistic statements like the above referenced look silly.
Lions Super Bowl Review
NOTE: Lions Super Bowl = NFL Draft
1st round - Stafford - I think this is a crap shoot. I don't think he's Peyton Manning but I don't think he's Akili Smith either. If he can be a 5 year starter - this is a success.
Brandon Pettigrew - I know the Lions need everything, but a TE at #20 - seems like a reach. Is the #1 TE in the draft going to be that much more of an impact than the #5 TE? the #10 TE. I've read he blocks like a tackle so his value could truly be higher than a typical TE, but I'm not fully convinced.
2nd round - Louis Delmas - I've read he was the #1 safety in the draft. With Maualuga and Laurinaitis still available (when people wanted the Lions to take Rey at #20) I'm surprised they didn't pick up a MLB. A theme here will be the Lions need everything so if Delmas is a starter, it seems like a win for me. Just watch out for the pro bowls from the mlbs they passed on...
3rd round - Levy - is an OLB - The Lions seem to be short term covered here with Sims (hopefully long term solution) and the off season addition of Julian Peterson.
Williams - remember when the one thing you could count on the Lions for is a good to great returner? - Lem Barney, Eddie Payton, Mel Gray, Terry Fair, Desmond Howard, Eddie Drummond- I think Williams could get back to that.
"The Professor and Mary Ann...." It is well known the "Experts" wanted the Lions to go OL and defense. The added a small college DT and a late round LB. The only OL they pick up is a 7th rounder. The remainder is a RB and ANOTHER TE.
My nemesis - Colin Blowhard is making a case (that I do not concede, by the way) that you judge the draft/off-season by the # of starts you added to your roster. I'm not convinced the Lions added too many starts to their season. Hopefully none for Stafford, is there always a TE starter? I'll give them 8 for Pettigrew. We'll assume Delmas can beat out whoever the Lions had at safety (+16). Peterson (not Levy) should add 16 at OLB. Maybe 4-5 from the rest. I'd predict 45-50 starts from new players, on a team that was winless that seems like a small number...
1st round - Stafford - I think this is a crap shoot. I don't think he's Peyton Manning but I don't think he's Akili Smith either. If he can be a 5 year starter - this is a success.
Brandon Pettigrew - I know the Lions need everything, but a TE at #20 - seems like a reach. Is the #1 TE in the draft going to be that much more of an impact than the #5 TE? the #10 TE. I've read he blocks like a tackle so his value could truly be higher than a typical TE, but I'm not fully convinced.
2nd round - Louis Delmas - I've read he was the #1 safety in the draft. With Maualuga and Laurinaitis still available (when people wanted the Lions to take Rey at #20) I'm surprised they didn't pick up a MLB. A theme here will be the Lions need everything so if Delmas is a starter, it seems like a win for me. Just watch out for the pro bowls from the mlbs they passed on...
3rd round - Levy - is an OLB - The Lions seem to be short term covered here with Sims (hopefully long term solution) and the off season addition of Julian Peterson.
Williams - remember when the one thing you could count on the Lions for is a good to great returner? - Lem Barney, Eddie Payton, Mel Gray, Terry Fair, Desmond Howard, Eddie Drummond- I think Williams could get back to that.
"The Professor and Mary Ann...." It is well known the "Experts" wanted the Lions to go OL and defense. The added a small college DT and a late round LB. The only OL they pick up is a 7th rounder. The remainder is a RB and ANOTHER TE.
My nemesis - Colin Blowhard is making a case (that I do not concede, by the way) that you judge the draft/off-season by the # of starts you added to your roster. I'm not convinced the Lions added too many starts to their season. Hopefully none for Stafford, is there always a TE starter? I'll give them 8 for Pettigrew. We'll assume Delmas can beat out whoever the Lions had at safety (+16). Peterson (not Levy) should add 16 at OLB. Maybe 4-5 from the rest. I'd predict 45-50 starts from new players, on a team that was winless that seems like a small number...
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
Cowherd
I am fortunate that I don't listen to him.
As far as the OL theory, you could probably do that with any other position. Especially if you combined positions to make 5 players (like an OL). You can measure a team's success on # of starts their DBs and the strong side LB have. I bet the numbers would be similar.
And you're absolutely right about his examples. That is selective sampling at its finest. Pick 5 teams that did well. See if they fit your theory. Use them as an example.
I don't get the NFL theory. Just that good teams have good picks so they trade them, and bad teams don't?
As far as the OL theory, you could probably do that with any other position. Especially if you combined positions to make 5 players (like an OL). You can measure a team's success on # of starts their DBs and the strong side LB have. I bet the numbers would be similar.
And you're absolutely right about his examples. That is selective sampling at its finest. Pick 5 teams that did well. See if they fit your theory. Use them as an example.
I don't get the NFL theory. Just that good teams have good picks so they trade them, and bad teams don't?
cause and effect
I'm stuck listening to Colin Cowherd (Blowhard) on espn radio. Two days in a row he has made statements as fact that I would argue need a little more investigation.
Yesterday - you can anticipate the number of wins for a college football team based on the #of starts the offensive linemen have coming into the season. He sighted examples of USC, Oklahoma, Alabama etc as having OL with >65 starts coming into the season. Some disappointing teams like Missouri (I don't remember the others) had inexperience OLs and that explains their relatively poor seasons. He was using this to say that Notre Dame will win 10+ games this year because they have 80+ starts in their OL. Hello Mr. Blowhard welcome to anecdotal evidence. I have no data to back it up but I would guess one could state an equal number of teams that had relatively few OL starts that were winners and teams with many OL starts that weren't. I'm not saying that OL experience isn't important, but there a many other things especially in college, that determine the teams ultimate record. ND might win 10 games because they have a pretty easy schedule. OSU could have a totally new line and I would still pick them to win the BigTen this season. USC might have complete turnover but I'm guessing they're going to have a chance to win the Pac10...
Today it is - good teams trade down in the draft, bad teams trade up. In the last X years the Patriots, Steelers, Giants etc have traded down and the Lions, Bengals and Raiders have traded up. Well guess what the Patriots, Steelers and Giants are good teams and likely don't to take a chance with as many rookies, where as the bad teams need a lot of help and might try to jump up to get someone they think they really need. You don't think the Lions want to trade down? No one wants to give them anything of "value". No one wants a top 5 pick this year...
Yesterday - you can anticipate the number of wins for a college football team based on the #of starts the offensive linemen have coming into the season. He sighted examples of USC, Oklahoma, Alabama etc as having OL with >65 starts coming into the season. Some disappointing teams like Missouri (I don't remember the others) had inexperience OLs and that explains their relatively poor seasons. He was using this to say that Notre Dame will win 10+ games this year because they have 80+ starts in their OL. Hello Mr. Blowhard welcome to anecdotal evidence. I have no data to back it up but I would guess one could state an equal number of teams that had relatively few OL starts that were winners and teams with many OL starts that weren't. I'm not saying that OL experience isn't important, but there a many other things especially in college, that determine the teams ultimate record. ND might win 10 games because they have a pretty easy schedule. OSU could have a totally new line and I would still pick them to win the BigTen this season. USC might have complete turnover but I'm guessing they're going to have a chance to win the Pac10...
Today it is - good teams trade down in the draft, bad teams trade up. In the last X years the Patriots, Steelers, Giants etc have traded down and the Lions, Bengals and Raiders have traded up. Well guess what the Patriots, Steelers and Giants are good teams and likely don't to take a chance with as many rookies, where as the bad teams need a lot of help and might try to jump up to get someone they think they really need. You don't think the Lions want to trade down? No one wants to give them anything of "value". No one wants a top 5 pick this year...
lions' draft, unis
I don't think the #1 pay for a LB is the same as a QB. And your own logic shows that it is less likely a #1 QB is worth being #1. I win.
As for the unis, I don't like the word logo, but everything else seems fine. Getting rid of some of the black is nice. The revamped bubbles is about the amount of change, and addition in detail, a logo should have at any one time. The numbers are goofy, but from a distance, or on the TV, we'll be able to read the numbers, I expect. The helmets look OK. Not like Texas, but still pretty good.
The uni blog guy really hates the color black and thick stripes. He must really hate zebras. HAHAHAHAHAH. Never a dull moment.
As for the unis, I don't like the word logo, but everything else seems fine. Getting rid of some of the black is nice. The revamped bubbles is about the amount of change, and addition in detail, a logo should have at any one time. The numbers are goofy, but from a distance, or on the TV, we'll be able to read the numbers, I expect. The helmets look OK. Not like Texas, but still pretty good.
The uni blog guy really hates the color black and thick stripes. He must really hate zebras. HAHAHAHAHAH. Never a dull moment.
Tuesday, April 21, 2009
lions' draft
I don't really know if I agree with anything you said. This team was BAD last year. Real bad. Placing a rookie QB in that position will only do one thing...ruin the QB. No QB put on a team as bad as this will ever be an above average QB in any situation. The only thing that could save him is to somehow get away from the Lions after 2 years. If he doesn't, he'll end up being an also ran.
As far as how it will affect the Lions, I think they need to just get a group of above average supporting members. It would be cheaper than a QB, they would likely be able to contribute now and there is better chance they can improve independent of what the rest of the team is doing. A great LB can play well on a bad defense. A great QB will be a bad QB on a bad offense.
All of my comments above, of course, are based on an assumption that the Lions will, someday soon, be heading in the right direction. I think 3 or 4 wins, would be real good this year. Unfortunately, 3-4 wins next year would probably be pretty good for the Lions, too.
So, might as well just get the QB, hope he doesn't play the piano, and throw him to the wolves (and the Bears and the Packers and the...)
As far as how it will affect the Lions, I think they need to just get a group of above average supporting members. It would be cheaper than a QB, they would likely be able to contribute now and there is better chance they can improve independent of what the rest of the team is doing. A great LB can play well on a bad defense. A great QB will be a bad QB on a bad offense.
All of my comments above, of course, are based on an assumption that the Lions will, someday soon, be heading in the right direction. I think 3 or 4 wins, would be real good this year. Unfortunately, 3-4 wins next year would probably be pretty good for the Lions, too.
So, might as well just get the QB, hope he doesn't play the piano, and throw him to the wolves (and the Bears and the Packers and the...)
Detroit Lions Draft
As usual, the Lions can't catch a break. When they get the #1 pick, there is no obvious #1 choice - not in a too many to choose from way - in a everyone is a late first round draft pick at best kind of way.
The options, according to the experts, are Aaron Curry - Wake Forest Linebacker, Jason Smith - Baylor OL, and Matthew Stafford - Georgia QB.
I'll admit I don't know anything about the first two, but I don't think that changes my opinion. When there is no clear choice I'd go with the QB. I think a QB is more likely to be "worth" #1 draft pick money. My only argument for going with one of the others would be the assumption that the Lions will be in the bottom 3-4 next year and be able to draft Bradford/McCoy...
The options, according to the experts, are Aaron Curry - Wake Forest Linebacker, Jason Smith - Baylor OL, and Matthew Stafford - Georgia QB.
I'll admit I don't know anything about the first two, but I don't think that changes my opinion. When there is no clear choice I'd go with the QB. I think a QB is more likely to be "worth" #1 draft pick money. My only argument for going with one of the others would be the assumption that the Lions will be in the bottom 3-4 next year and be able to draft Bradford/McCoy...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)